This article is Part 4 in the Exploring Orchestral Music series.
The Deep Dive
My goal for this blog series was to write about ways to explore and enjoy orchestral music. So, as part of going over the Spotify and Apple Music stats in detail, I wanted to highlight the small number of composers in each playlist that were women, Black, Indigenous, and/or people of colour. This way, you can discover more about them and get to know their music.
There’s a really interesting range of artists featured on both streaming services, ranging from composers from as early as the 17th century to some modern musicians who have built careers in and around the streaming platforms.
Using 2019/20 orchestra seasons as a benchmark
To provide a benchmark, each playlist below is compared to a hypothetical playlist where the number of composers who are women; Black, Indigenous, or people of colour; or both is proportional to how often these composers are programmed by the average US orchestra.
This “average US orchestra” calculation is based on the 2019/20 season analysis of 120 US orchestras from the Institute for Composer Diversity. The ICD analysis found that only 7.9% of works on mainstage programs were by women composers, and only 5.6% were by composers from underrepresented racial, ethnic, or cultural heritages. A full summary of their findings is included in the table below:
|Full ICD List||“Top 21” from ICD List *|
|Women||321 (7.9%)||104 (7.0%)|
|BIPOC **||236 (5.8%)||67 (4.5%)|
|BIPOC Women||77 (1.9%)||24 (1.6%)|
|Living||658 (16.1%)||241 (16.2%)|
This subgroup of 21 of the largest US orchestras will come up later when I talk about the ICD analysis in more detail. It is the original group analyzed by the Baltimore Symphony for the 2014/15 season and the group that has continued to be analyzed by Women’s Philharmonic Advocacy from 2016/17 to the present.
The designation used by the Institute for Composer Diversity is “Composers from Underrepresented Racial, Ethnic, or Cultural Heritages”. My understanding is that this comprises composers who are Black, Indigenous, or people of colour.
Labels for Composers who are Black, Indigenous, or People of Colour
Since the intention of the BIPOC acronym is to specifically highlight the unique experiences of Black and Indigenous people, and not to be a catch-all for people who are not white, I’ve only used it in acronym form when talking about a group that includes all of the identities the acronym implies and when the acronym is warranted due to space limitations.
When talking about a group that does not include all the identities that BIPOC implies, I’ve written out the specific identities that are included. When talking about an individual artist, I’ve tried to use their specific identity, as they describe it.
The NPR podcast Code Switch had a good episode on the BIPOC acronym and the various opinions people have about it.
One important thing to note is that the labels used in the tables below only describe the specific identities of the composers actually featured in each playlist. However, the Average US Orchestra numbers should always be understood to imply the potential for broader representation.
Apple Music is often seen as a streaming platform that cares more about the experience of classical music listeners. Their app does a better job of displaying pieces of music that have multiple movements, and their metadata is more suited to the genre. Unlike Spotify, they have a pretty reliable “composer” field for most tracks.
However, this increased attention to the genre hasn’t resulted in composer representation that keeps up with the field, as you can see in the playlists examined below.
|Classical Essentials||If Average US Orchestra|
|People of Colour||0||6|
|Women of Colour||0||2|
As you can see, there are no composers of colour represented on this playlist.
One interesting thing about all of the three women composers on this playlist is that they are partially known for having deep musical and personal relationships with another person: Fanny Mendelssohn with her brother Felix, Nadia Boulanger, with her sister Lili, and Clara Schumann with her husband Robert.
Fanny Mendelssohn: String Quartet in E-Flat Major: I. Adagio ma non troppo
Fanny Mendelssohn (14 November 1805 – 14 May 1847), later Fanny [Cäcilie] Mendelssohn Bartholdy and, after her marriage, Fanny Hensel, also referred to as Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel, was a German composer and pianist of the early Romantic era. Her compositions include a piano trio, a piano quartet, an orchestral overture, four cantatas, more than 125 pieces for the piano, and over 250 lieder, most of which went unpublished in her lifetime. Although praised for her piano technique, she rarely gave public performances outside her family circle.
The first movement of this string quartet is really good - I see why they chose it for the playlist. Apparently she never formally learned to play any string instruments, and also was self-deprecating about this particular piece, which I think is sad:
She was also undoubtedly hampered by the fact that, unlike her brother, she had never studied or played any string instruments, experience which would have assisted her in writing chamber or orchestral works… After completing her string quartet, she wrote to Felix in 1835, “I lack the ability to sustain ideas properly and give them the needed consistency. Therefore lieder suit me best, in which, if need be, merely a pretty idea without much potential for development can suffice.”
Lili Boulanger & Nadia Boulanger: Lux Aeterna (For Voice, Harp, Violin And Cello)
Juliette Nadia Boulanger (16 September 1887 – 22 October 1979) was a French composer, conductor, and teacher. She is notable for having taught many of the leading composers and musicians of the 20th century. She also performed occasionally as a pianist and organist.
Marie-Juliette Olga “Lili” Boulanger (21 August 1893 – 15 March 1918) was a French composer, and the first female winner of the Prix de Rome composition prize. Her older sister was the noted composer and composition teacher Nadia Boulanger.
The history of this piece is quite interesting — in an article titled Nadia and Lili Boulanger: Sister Composers, Dr. Caroline Potter notes that Lux Aeterna is the second version of the song; the first was Cantique, a setting of a poem from a play named Soeur Béatrice by Belgian playwright Maurice Maeterlinck 1. Potter, Caroline. “Nadia and Lili Boulanger: Sister Composers.” The Musical Quarterly, vol. 83, no. 4, 1999, pp. 536–556. JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/742616. Accessed 24 Jan. 2021. Dr. Potter observes that Cantique is heavily influenced by Gabriel Fauré’s Lydia and has very similar opening chords 2. The key difference between the openings of Fauré’s Lydia and Boulanger’s Cantique, according to Dr. Potter, is that Fauré used the Lydian mode as a musical pun. Nadia Boulanger later re-orchestrated Cantique and set it to the text of the Lux Aeterna for a mass commemorating Lili’s (early) death.
Although Apple Music credits the song to both sisters, this seems to be incorrect. The Library of Congress credits Nadia as the sole composer, though it notes that she intended to have her orchestration match Lili’s Pie Jesu in the reworking of the song. The liner notes for the album note that “Since 1918, Nadia’s Lux Aeterna and Lili’s Pie Jesu have been sung every 15th March at a memorial Mass in Paris”.
Clara Schumann: Scherzo No. 2 in C Minor, Op. 14
Clara Josephine Schumann (née Wieck; 13 September 1819 – 20 May 1896) was a German pianist, composer and piano teacher. Regarded as one of the most distinguished pianists of the Romantic era, she exerted her influence over a 61-year concert career, changing the format and repertoire of the piano recital from displays of virtuosity to programs of serious works. She also composed solo piano pieces, a piano concerto (her Op. 7), chamber music, choral pieces, and songs.
If you like this piece, Isata Kanneh-Mason recorded a whole album of pieces by Clara Schumann in 2019, including this one.
|Relaxing Classical||If Average US Orchestra|
|People of Colour||0||3|
|Women of Colour||0||1|
Again, no composers of colour.
While researching both of the women composers featured on this playlist, I came across the Swedish Musical Heritage Website, which is a project initiated by The Royal Swedish Academy of Music. Thanks to this site, you can read detailed biographies for both composers and even download a lot of their sheet music for free.
Helena Munktell: Kleines Trio: II. Andante espressivo
Helena Mathilda Munktell (24 November 1852 – 10 September 1919) was a Swedish composer.
From the liner notes: “The third work on this disc is a small-scale piano trio, probably an early work and possibly composed for performance at one of the musical salons at the Munktell family home in Stockholm.”
There were no works by Munktell included in the League analysis of 120 US orchestra mainstage programs, however, there is a 2005 album of her orchestral works by the Gälve Symphony Orchestra. An untapped opportunity for orchestras looking to increase the number of women on the program, perhaps. Despite the fact that I spent a lot of a previous post talking about how women and people of colour should be programmed more in the back half of orchestra programs, I think her symphonic poem Bränningar (Breaking Waves) would make a great opener.
Amanda Rontgen-Maier: Violin Sonata in B Minor: II. Andantino
Amanda Röntgen-Maier (20 February 1853 – 15 July 1894) was a Swedish violinist and composer. She was the first female graduate in music direction from the Royal College of Music in Stockholm in 1872.
My favourite fact about this Sonata, according to her biography, is that when she submitted it to the Swedish Art Music Society, one of the three men who reviewed it suggested she change the slow movement. To which she basically said “no, I like it too much the way it is”. The result: “The sonata was printed without any alterations and published in 1878.”
The A-List: Classical
|The A-List: Classical||If Average US Orchestra|
|Black / People of Colour||2 (3.9%)||3|
|Women of Colour||0||1|
As I understand it, Apple Music’s “A-List” playlists are where they program new releases. The kinds of music on this playlist range from new recordings of the kinds of classical composers you might see on an orchestra program to instrumental streaming artists who primarily make their living based on placement on mood-themed playlists.
Both of the two composers of colour that were featured on this playlist are in the latter category of musicians who have made careers primarily as streaming artists.
Sofiane Pamart: San Francisco
Sofiane Pamart is a French pianist, based in Paris and originally from Hellemmes in the suburbs of Lille. He is known to the French public for breaking the elitist codes of classical piano.
Every track on Pamart’s Planet Gold album is geographically-named, so consider this a fun way to get the thrill of travelling while staying safe at home. San Francisco in particular I thought was pretty hypnotic and cinematic. It reminded me a lot of Christopher Larkin’s very popular Hollow Knight soundtrack, which I think speaks to Pamart’s ability to create a strong sense of atmosphere that really fuels your imagination.
Alexis Ffrench: A Time for Giving
Alexis Ffrench (born 1970) is a British classical soul pioneer, composer, producer and pianist. Not only is Ffrench the UK’s biggest selling pianist of 2020, he has headlined London’s Royal Albert Hall, collaborated with fashion houses Miyake and Hugo Boss, played Latitude Festival, worked with Paloma Faith, composed several film scores and shares the same management team as Little Mix and Niall Horan.
This reminds me of the kinds of music my mum used to play on the piano while people were coming in to church. Which makes sense in a certain way — Alexis Ffrench often talks about how he grew up playing the organ at church and the role that spirituality has in his music.
If you like this song, you should also check out his performance of the Bluebird Suite with orchestra at the Classic BRIT Awards 2018, which also features South African singer Pretty Yende.
Streaming Artists and Their Audience
Artists who have been able to make a career on streaming platforms playing classical instruments often get asked in interviews some variant of a question “how do you feel about the fact that you’re not making serious classical music?”
Sometimes the implication is that their talent is being wasted on an audience who is primarily assumed to be writing emails while listening, other times it’s a nastier implication that they make simple, uncomplicated music with little “high art” merit. I don’t think it’s a particularly fair or meaningful question, but I do find that the variety of responses that these artists give is interesting.
The best answers seem to turn the question on its head: instead of being about “is your art valuable” (as judged by the existing gatekeepers), it becomes about the relationship each artist has with their audience, and the value that the audience gets from their music.
Sofiane Pamart talks about this in a recent interview:
How do you respond to the classical purists, who remain unconvinced?
… The important thing is to touch, to be moved. That goes beyond the technical repertoire. That comes later. It’s interesting to understand how an artist creates, but that comes later. I’m very happy to move away from that. If it does you good to tell you that there are winks at Debussy, I’m very happy, and if you have no classical references and it makes you think of film music or something else, I’m very comfortable with that.
Alexis Ffrench has a good answer too, I think:
Crucially, this means “breaking down perceived barriers”, therefore the power of the three-and-a-half-minute message should not be underestimated. “You can write 40-minute symphonies, but it’s more important to me to connect with people at this stage.” All of his singles on Spotify are under four minutes long and his new album is “tuneful,” despite many classical artists seeing this a “dirty word”.
Doesn’t it bother that the compositions you work so hard on are often listened to as background music?
‘There are also Debussy arrangements, or pieces by Vikingur Olafsson. Just because people use them as a background doesn’t mean the music is bad. And apart from that: is one listener worth more than another? When I bring someone to a transcendental metaphysical insight with my music, I love it. And if I can help an official through his first tax check on a Monday morning, that’s fine.’
[Via Google Translate - the original article is in Dutch]
Even Peter Gelb answers emails while listening to the Met Opera rehearse. That’s the great thing about music: it can be enjoyed many different ways. Sometimes it can bring joy to your life in the background, and sometimes it can be an all-encompassing artistic experience.
Milana Zilnik: Dicembre
Milana is a multi-award winning pianist, composer and singer-songwriter, who has been a performing and recording artist since her childhood. A strong lyricist and composer in her own right, Milana’s style is reminiscent of Tori Amos, Sarah McLachlan, Michael Nyman, Keith Jarret and Chick Corea. Milana enjoys playing by ear, improvising and using whatever inspires her to create her own style of playing. She is known as an adept improviser, catching melodies on the fly and expanding them into her own creations.
A Canadian!! I too would write sad piano music if I lived in Ottawa year-round.
Amanda Rontgen-Maier: Violin Sonata in B Minor: II. Andantino
This track was also featured in Apple Music’s Relaxing Classical playlist.
|Classical Kids||If Average US Orchestra|
|People of Colour||0||3|
|Women of Colour||0||1|
Of these 50, three of the tracks are nursery rhymes with no known composer, one did not have an identifiable composer listed (Classical Piano Music for Baby Sleep by Baby Lullaby Academy), and one was not a piece of music, but rather an audiobook chapter read by Michael Morpurgo. These unknown composers are not omitted for the percentage calculations — see the methodology section for more details.
The theoretical underpinning of this whole exercise is “what classical music do new listeners find on streaming platforms”, and no listeners are newer than children. Pretty disappointing that this whole playlist has no women or people of colour at all.
Of course, music for children has the same representation issues as music for any other audience. Billboard recently reported that “three of this year’s five Grammy nominees for best children’s music album asked the Recording Academy to withdraw their nominations to signal their disappointment that all the nominees in the category are white and only one is female.”
Next Up: Spotify
The Spotify classical playlists were longer than those on Apple Music, and had greater representation of composers who are women and composers who are Black, Indigenous, or people of colour. So I’ll split my Spotify deep dive into two or three posts so that I can talk about all the tracks in proper detail.
Full methodology notes for all my music posts can be found via the Main Methodology Page.
Details and data for the streaming service playlists analysis can be found on the Streaming Analysis Methodology Page.
More details about how I used the data from the Institute for Composer Diversity to create the comparison to US orchestra mainstage seasons can be found on the ICD 2019/20 Season Analysis Methodology Page.
Articles in the Exploring Orchestral Music series:
- Part 1 - Exploring Orchestral Music via a Favourite Instrument
- Part 2 - Exploring Orchestral Music: Race and Gender Representation of Composers
- Part 3 - Representation of Composers in Top Classical Playlists on Spotify and Apple Music
- Part 4 - Deep Dive: Composer Representation in Apple Music Classical Playlists (Current Page)